Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Back to Basics: Project Description and Ecosystem-based Adaptation

OK, time to get serious and talk about some research. My next couple of posts will describe some research-related site visits I've done in the last few months.  To get everyone on the same page, I thought I would start with some background on what exactly it is that I'm doing here in India. For those of you who are just here for the pictures, I won't be offended if you skip ahead to the next post.

My original Fulbright proposal was to research adaptation to climate change in the particular context of India. I'm interested in both the high-level policy perspective (as in what institutional players are involved, where the money is coming from, etc), as well as the grass-roots perspective (what does an on-the-ground adaptation project look like?). For those of you new to this field (as I was before coming here), the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) defines adaptation as the “adjustment in natural or human systems in response to actual or expected climatic stimuli or their effects, which moderates harm or exploits beneficial opportunities”.  Adaptation has frequently been overshadowed by greenhouse gas mitigation in international climate change agreements.  While mitigation strives to reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases, the cause of climate change, adaptation acknowledges the critical importance of preparing and planning for the inevitable impacts of climate change even while trying to stop it.  Even if all greenhouse gas emissions were to stop tomorrow, the carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide and fluorinated gases already in the atmosphere from human activity would continue to cause climate impacts for centuries to come. 

Adaptation is an issue of immediate relevance for both developing and developed countries, as sea level rise, changing temperature and precipitation patterns, and associated impacts on habitat and biodiversity will affect every nation on the planet.  However, because the best adaptation to climate change is to be rich, poorer segments of the population in developing countries will suffer the worst impacts.  It is a particularly cruel irony that these poor and natural resource-dependent people who had no role in creating the problem will suffer the worst impacts. The few existing international funding sources available for adaptation assistance recognize only the poorest nations. India does not fall into this category and thus, climate change adaptation projects undertaken in India must primarily be organized and funded internally. 

Adaptation to climate change can take many forms and can occur at the individual, community, or government level.  Everything from buying an air-conditioning unit to planting drought-resistant crops to designing infrastructure projects to withstand extreme weather can constitute adaptation.  My project focuses on a specific subset of adaptation known as ecosystem-based adaptation. This type of adaptation acknowledges the connection between ecosystem health and human health and well-being.  Ecosystem-based adaption helps human communities adapt to climate change by generating economic opportunity, building resilience in natural systems, and mitigating the harmful impacts of climate change. Rural, resource-dependent communities most at risk from climate change will be the primary beneficiaries of ecosystem adaptation projects.    

Since coming to Delhi in November 2010, I've been working with the Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) on two of their ecosystem-based adaptation projects. I've also been pursuing a few independent projects of my own. My next few posts will describe some of these projects and case studies in different parts of the country. 

Wednesday, June 1, 2011

God's Own Country

Except for my brief trip to Mumbai, I had not yet had the opportunity to venture out of northern, Hindi-speaking India, or "Hindia", as I like to call it. So rather than returning to Delhi after the Fulbright conference in Goa, it was time to venture down further south to see what the rest of this crazy sub-continent is all about.

Exiting the cool dimness of the night train from Goa to Ernakulam in the southern state of Kerala, we stepped into a steamy world of palm trees, flooded rice fields, and European colonial influences. My painfully acquired Hindi was of no use in this part of the country - Malayalam ( മലയാളം ) is the linuga franca in Kerala.

South India is, on average, wealthier and better educated than much of north India.  Kerala is a prime example, with the highest literacy rate in India (94.6%) and some of the lowest levels of corruption. Like Goa, Kerala has a certain European flare due to centuries of occupation by the Portuguese, Dutch, and finally the British. Kerala and West Bengal are unique in India in having elected communist governments.

Kerala's most famous attraction is the backwaters, an intricate network of brackish lakes connected by rivers and man-made canals extending almost half the length of the state. The area is rich in animal life, especially birds and aquatic beasties like giant prawns and mud skippers. Renting a houseboat that rather resembled a giant water beetle, we spent a wonderful 24 hours cruising the backwaters, stopping occasionally to birdwatch, eat fresh fruit, and swim.  The backwaters are a place where the Kerala department of tourism's motto "God's Own Country" seems like a pretty apt description.

Houseboat on the Kerala backwaters

Our second stop in Kerala was Kochi, or Fort Cochin to you British imperialists out there.  Located on the northern tip of an island just offshore, Kochi is an adorable tourist paradise of street side cafes and brightly painted alleys, Christian churches and Chinese fishing nets. It's also a good place to see a bit of Kathakali, a form of classical Indian dance involving lots of makeup and stylized movement. A full performance can take 7-8 hours. We, being shallow tourists with short attention spans, went to the 1.5 hour abbreviated version.

Kathakali dancers preparing for a performance
Huge cantilever fishing nets installed along the shoreline
Kerala - the land of the lungi and dhoti (colored or white cloths men wear around their waists in lieu of trousers)






Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Going to Goa

At the beginning of March, a giant sucking sound was heard as Fulbright participants of every description emerged from the crevices of south and central Asia to congregate in the beach-side paradise of Goa on India's southwest coast.  The annual Fulbright conference is a much anticipated event.  Held every year in a different location, it brings together student researchers, senior scholars, visiting lectures and other types of Fulbrighters from India, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Kazakhstan  Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan for a week of lectures, cultural events, field trips, and excellent networking.  And we got to stay in a Taj Hotel - not too shabby. 

The conference was a great opportunity to learn what other Fulbrighters are up to.  Check out these other Fulbright blogs for an insight into the diversity of Fulbright research.                                                        



Municipal garbage in Delhi:     http://wastelines.com/
An artist's impressions of India's Grand Trunk Road:     http://thielkerstudio.blogspot.com/
Black carbon emissions in Delhi:     http://newenvironmentality.blogspot.com/
Painting and photography in Rajasthan:   http://bigbangstudio.blogspot.com/
Solar lighting technology in rural India:  http://solarvillages.blogspot.com/
Sustainable food systems in India:   http://laurenfinzer.blogspot.com/
Effects of supermarkets on Indian food consumption:  http://rotiandriceperambulations.blogspot.com/

....and probably the most bad-ass Fulbright project I've ever heard of:  Traditional hunting with golden eagles  in Kyrgyzstan:   http://keenonkyrgyzstan.com/      Yeah, how cool is that?

Inspired?  Lucky for you, the 2012-13 Fulbright competition is now open. Go to http://us.fulbrightonline.org/home.html to check it out.

Goa is India’s smallest state by geographical area but only 4th smallest by population.  It’s also India’s richest state, with a GDP 2.5 times that of the country average. About 30% of Goa’s population is Catholic, compared to just over 2% for India as a whole. This can be largely attributed to early Portuguese influence in Goa. The Portuguese explorer Vasco da Gama traveled around the Cape of Good Hope to first reach India in 1498, landing at the port of Calicut in Kerala several hundred kilometers to the south.  By the early 16th century Portuguese traders were active in Goa, and by 1510 laid siege to the city. Goa remained an overseas territory of Portugal until 1961, when Indian troops invaded and forced the surrender of the Portuguese forces. The cultural influence of the Portuguese is still very evident in Goa's churches, wide plazas, and European architecture. Goa is also known for its beaches and pill-poppin' party scene, which, being an upstanding U.S. State Department-funded researcher, I did not participate in.


Catholic church in Panjim, Goa's capitol

Waterways crisscrossing Panjim, complete with atmospheric rusty ships

Traditional fishing in action: set up the net, wait for the tide to go out, and see what you've got

Beaches of Goa:  No lifeguard on duty

Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Words of Wisdom

    When I first arrived in India, way back in August 2010, I was confused, overwhelmed, and a little intimidated by the colorful chaos of this country. People, dogs, cows, traffic and *HONK HONK*.  So on day #3, while sitting in a taxi travelling from Dehradun to Mussourie, I took comfort in a series of earnest signs along the road extolling the virtues of tree-planting and environmental protection.  Despite the somewhat socialist and hippy, circle-of-life-ish implications, here were some sentiments I could relate to. Here's a selection for your reading pleasure.

Tree means water
Water means bread
Bread means life


Make the world a 
happy place for 
the people to live in


Prosperity through forestry

     .....and my favorite:
 Consume wisely
Conserve widely

These sentiments and signs date from the early 1980's, during which time there was a national effort to combat environmental degradation in mountainous regions though tree planting on a massive scale.

Another type of helpful road-side message widely seen throughout India concerns drunk driving.


Speed thrills
But kills


With whiskey
Driving risky


Better to be Mr. Late
Than late Mr.


Well said, National Highways Authority of India.  Well said.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Indian Animal Fashion


       There are a lot of people in India, and possibly just as many stray dogs. Back when it was cold in Delhi (revealing how far behind I am on posts - it's now pushing 100 F every day!), many of these lucky puppies were on the street sporting a variety of bizarre coats.  More dogs than not had some kind of blanket, t-shirt, sheet, burlap sack, etc tied around their midsection, insulating them from the sometimes bitterly cold central Indian winter.   

     I couldn't figure it out - is this some kind of civic service the municipal government provides?  Or were kind-hearted civilians taking it upon themselves to winterize their local stray canine(s). Now that the weather is hot again, the doggy coats have entirely disappeared   Another Indian mystery.


     Another dog fashion I recently encountered comes to us from the middle Himalaya in north-western Uttarakhand state. This fuzzy fella is sporting the latest in massive metal collar.  Why, you ask?  Looks uncomfortable.  Well, less uncomfortable than having your throat chewed out by a leopard.  Leopard predation on dogs is a big problem in many parts of rural India.  Most dogs just have to take their chances, but a special few, like this guy, are valuable enough to a sheep or cattle-herding operation that they get fitted with this kind of protection.


     However I think the award for best-dressed animal I've seen to date in India is this stylin' goat from Agra.  This was during the cold season as well, so as with the Delhi dogs, perhaps some thoughtful person was being kind to the animals. Alternative scenario?  A reincarnated auto driver with bad karma for ripping off too many foreigners.  



Sunday, May 8, 2011

Ladakh Wrap-up

Dried-fruit and nut vendor in the Leh bazaar

Mission #3:  Don't Die

Of our three missions, I'm pleased that #3 was not the one we failed to accomplish.  Although there were a few close calls.  The whole walking-over-melting-river-ice thing, for instance.  And then there was the time when I was minding my own business, climbing up a steep patch of scree in search of a snow leopard when I rather suddenly had to throw myself across the hillside to avoid a falling boulder, dislodged by he-who-will-remain-nameless. And then there were the inevitable ice-covered, potholed ledges along the edges of gorges that pass for roads in this part of the world.  At least we had one snow chain.  Um, yeah, ONE snow chain.  Seems like getting two snow chains wouldn't be that much harder than getting one, but what do I know.  How do you decide what tire to put it on?  And let's not forget the uber sketchy zip-line/crate by which we crossed the Zanskar river. R. had a great deal of fun in listing all the numerous ways in which we might 1) get our fingers (or hair, in my case) stuck in the winch, and 2) fall into the river when the re-bar-reinforced wooden box we were sitting in fell apart half way across
.




While in the Leh airport waiting lounge prior to boarding our flight back to Delhi, a nice young man walked up to us to tell us that he had just skied across Antarctica. I guess he just wanted someone to talk to who would appreciate his experience.  Little did he suspect that we would also be Antarctic veterans, and could totally talk shop with him (although his experiences were a little more hard-core than mine). Not 10 days before he had completed the first Indian army ski expedition across Antarctica from Hercules Inlet to the geographic South Pole. The team of 8 skied 1170 km over 50 days, finally arriving at the South Pole on January 14th.  Being native to Leh, our new friend was better prepared than most Indians for the rigors of the frozen continent. Read more about their expedition here.    

Us with the Indian army Antarctic skier in the Leh airport

For those of you who need another snow leopard fix, check out some consummate snow leopard footage here from the BBC Planet Earth series.  And finally, a few pics of some awesome Leh beasties for all you animal lovers out there.

Blue sheep (or bharal), and preferred snow leopard prey
...and my favorite donkey in the whole world!

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

In Search of the Snow Leopard

Mission 2:  See a Snow Leopard

The Prelude

One fine autumn evening last year while sitting at an outdoor table at the Tip Top Teashop in Mussourie, three Hindi students began to discuss how awesome it would be to see a snow leopard in the wild.   For me, the conversation was entirely theoretical at first.  I mean, come on, how many of those things are there left in the world anyway, like six?  Such an expedition would involve expensive things like guides and good outdoor gear.  And not least of all, it’s flippin’ cold in Ladakh in February. But as we continued to discuss and research, the idea began to seem more feasible. 

The Background

Snow leopards are found in the high reaches of the Himalayan mountains and on the Tibetan plateau.  Their range stretches from eastern Afghanistan in the west, through Pakistan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan and Kyrgystan to Mongolia and Siberia in the east, and from China in the north down through the Himalayan mountains to Nepal and India in the south.  The best place to see snow leopards in India is in the state of Jammu and Kashmir in the district of Ladakh, a land north of the main Himalayan range. The landscape here is extreme - cold, precipitous, and high, as can be seen in this photo taken from the airplane. Looking for a snow leopard here is like looking for a flea in a farmyard.  

Snow leopard county, as seen from an airplane
The snow leopard (Panthera uncia) is a big cat weighing  between 27 to 55 kg .  Usually a solitary beast, snow leopards only travel in pairs during the late winter mating season.  Their main prey in their Indian range is the bharal (Himalayan blue sheep) that also frequent the high mountain passes of Ladakh.  Various estimates put the world-wide snow leopard population in the wild between 4,000 and 7,000, while the Indian population of snow leopards is estimated to be between 100-200 animals. (In contrast, according to the results of the 2010 tiger census, India has an estimated 1,706 tigers.) Snow leopards are notoriously difficult to study.  Their mountainous habitat, secretive nature, and perfect camouflage make sightings rare. Considered the holy grail for wildlife spotters, only around 1,000 foreigners have ever had the privilege of seeing a snow leopard in the wild.  We would be exceedingly lucky if we were to see one.

Most people who get a bee in their bonnet about snow leopards sign up for expensive guided expeditions run by a handful of eco-tourism companies.  These 10-12 day trips can set you back around $4,000, not including international airfare from your home country.  We, being cheap, decided to free-style it.  We found several sample snow leopard trip itineraries online, and from these determined that our best bet was to plan an expedition to the Rumbak valley within Hemis National Park, south of Leh.  Hemis National Park is a massive mountainous landscape, understandably one of the least visited national parks in the country.  It provides critical territory to IUCN red listed endangered animals, including the Tibetan wild ass, the black-necked crane, and wolves.  In the summer snow leopards live above the tree line between 3,000 and 6,000 meters, but in the winter, follow prey to lower altitudes.  So although it’s a bit counter-intuitive that mid-winter is the best time for snow-leopard spotting, this is when the animals are most accessible. 

The Plan

We returned to Leh after our aborted Chadar River trek and immediately began to gear up again for our second expedition.  This time we would be less mobile – one fixed camp would be set up in the Rumbak valley, midway between two side valleys called the Tarbung and Husing valleys.  These two valleys and the Rumbak valley between them is the closest thing around to a snow leopard super-highway.  Which is to say, maybe 5-7 snow leopards are sighted there a year - after thousands of man-hours of searching. Not such great odds. Like many big cats, snow leopards are most active in the morning and evening.  Every day we would rise early and be scanning the slopes in one of the two valleys by 6am.  We would return to camp for breakfast around 9:30am, and then spend the late morning and afternoon roaming the valley floors for fresh tracks and other signs.  Around 4pm we would again take up our station on a hillside, watching the boulders and snow slopes for movement or a rock at appeared to have ears.

After hiring two experienced guides and a cook, we repacked our bags and set off from Leh to Hemis National Park.  We had rented a larger kitchen tent in anticipation of needing a space to stay warm in the evenings.  It was such a bulky thing that we had to hire three tiny donkeys at the base of the valley where the road ended to carry our gear up to the camping spot.  Our first morning was spent setting up camp on one of the few flat spots in the narrow valley.  We found another group already there – a well-equiped expedition of seven clients, three guides and a number of porters organized through Zegrahm Expeditions. 

Our campsite in the Rumbak valley
The Chase

On our first morning we rose early and by 6:30am were scanning the slopes from a high vantage point up the Husing valley.  The grey, cold morning was utterly quite, the silence broken only by the occasional call of a bird.  We divided the hillsides around us into sections and each took responsibility for searching one area.  Around 7:30 one of the guides saw something; what he originally took to be a blue sheep was suddenly revealed to have a long furry tail. The animal disappeared behind a rock before anyone else got a look. Suddenly excited, we bounded further up the hill to try to get a look. Several minutes later, R. found tracks in the snow from two leopards travelling together – likely a mating pair. One set of tracks had a reoccurring spot of blood in one of the prints, an injury sustained from the sharp rock scree covering the slopes at that altitude.  We followed the tracks over the mountainside and the chase was on!

Knowing the snow leopards were travelling much faster than we were over the steep and rocky terrain, we still felt compelled to follow them in the hopes of catching a glimpse of them in the distance.  We trailed them for 3 hours, gaining and losing hundreds of meters in elevation as we picked our way over the shoulders of the mountains.  R., with the fortitude and sure-footedness of a young goat, bounded ahead with the guides, following the tracks as they passed over snow, scree and boulders.  I lagged behind, lacking the energy for this type of extreme trekking before breakfast.   Finally around mid-day, high on the mountainside, it became evident that we could follow no further.  The tracks disappeared down a slope too steep to follow.  Regretfully we turned back, picking our way hundreds of meters back down the mountain to camp.
The view from our highest vantage point on the trek, and where we had to turn back
The Sighting

Upon reaching camp close to 2pm, we fell upon our neglected breakfast like a pack of ravenous wolves.  My shoes were wet and my clothes were all torn up from our morning’s adventures, so after getting a little food in my belly I pulled the insoles out of my boots to dry and removed my shredded wind pants, settling down to eat in my long underwear.  Suddenly there was a commotion outside of the tent – shouts echoed up and down the valley, and suddenly people seemed to be moving, running.  I tossed aside my plate, and shoving my feet into my sole-less boots, took off down the valley with my shoe laces flapping, wearing only my long underwear and a thin sweater.  I wasn’t exactly sure what had caused the sudden urgency, but members of the other expedition were headed down towards the Husing valley, and the only thing I could think was “SNOW LEOPARD!”.

Finally reaching the opening to the valley, I could see the guides and the faster members of the two groups already sitting 50 meters up the scree slope with binoculars and spotting scopes trained high up the hillside.  They obviously had something in view, and so, pausing ever-so-briefly to tie my boots, I flung myself up the slope, terrified that whatever they were looking at would disappear before I could get a look.  I reached the group dirty, cold and half-dressed, and peering through a spotting scope at the opposite side of the valley, I saw it.  The snow leopard. 
Snow leopard spotting
The handsome beast was almost a kilometer away, stalking right along the top of the ridge line on the opposite side of the valley.  Silhouetted against the sky as it was, I could even see puffs of its hot breath condensing in the cold afternoon air.  The leopard’s enormously long and thick tail curved up elegantly behind it.  After a moment it sat down just behind the ridge line, leaving only its head visible.  I attempted to take some pictures through the spotting scope, with the following result.


You can tell that's a snow leopard, right?  Fortunately, we don't have to rely entirely on my inadequate camera technology. Our friends in the other expedition had far better equipment and were generous enough to share some of their images.  Here they are, folks.  Our view of the snow leopard, one of the rarest wildlife sightings in the world.

Photo credit: Jonathan Rossouw 
Photo credit: Jonathan Rossouw 
After resting on top of the ridge for a few minutes, the snow leopard came back towards us, descending just a little down into our valley. At one point it stopped to spray urine on a rock in a territorial scent-marking behavior.  We continued to watch, sharing the few spotting scopes between us.  Finally, after almost an hour, as dusk began to fall, the leopard disappeared into the gloom between two boulders, and we did not see it again.  Happily, we shuffled off to our camps, ecstatic to have been so lucky.

Snow leopard tracks
Shockingly, our sighting occurred on the first full day of the trip. We still had 4 days in the valley to try to replicate the experience.  Every morning and evening we braved the sub-freezing temperatures to sit on hillsides, scanning the slopes for movement.  Signs were everywhere. Most mornings we would find fresh tracks in the snow on the valley floor, sometimes passing within a hundred meters of the tents. One evening we were up on the hillside in the gathering dusk, preparing to return to camp, when we heard a low moaning cry echoing through the valley. Our guides, Jingmet and Panchok, recognized the noise as the call of a male leopard searching for a female.  We ran up the hill to a viewpoint and spent the last half hour of light scanning the valley below.  Although we heard the call several more times, landscape was completely still. The same call, kind of a choking moan, was heard during the night on several more evenings.  But we never saw one again.  After our early success this was disappointing, but we were very cognizant of our extreme luck in seeing one so early on.  It was very exciting to see the tracks and hear the calls, daily evidence that the cats were still there, slipping like ghosts through the scree and boulder fields.

And that, friends, is how we were able to join the small group of westerners who have seen a snow leopard in the wild.  Pretty awesome.

For another account of our snow leopard experience, see the blog of another trip member here.

Scanning for movement after hearing a mating call

The team: We three, our guides Jingmet and Panchok, and our cook/camp manager Samstan